Private mailbox or PO Box?
Both hold your mail securely. The real differences are the address you get, who can deliver to it, and what happens when a package needs a signature.
| Private mailbox here | USPS PO Box | |
|---|---|---|
| Your address | A real street address: 11519 Kingston Pike, Farragut, TN 37934, with your own box number | A PO Box number at the post office. USPS Street Addressing lets many boxes also use the post office’s street address for deliveries, where offered |
| Who can deliver | Every carrier: UPS, FedEx, USPS, DHL, and Amazon | USPS only, unless Street Addressing is set up; some carriers and items are still excluded |
| Packages needing a signature | Our staff sign for them and hold them securely until you come in | Held at the post office counter or a parcel locker; you collect them on their schedule |
| Access | 24/7: you get a front-door key when you sign up, so any hour of any day | Post office lobby hours, which vary by location |
| Oversized packages | Accepted and held for you, even when they would never fit in the box | Limited by box and locker size; anything bigger waits behind the counter with a notice in your box |
| Using it for a business | A street address you can put on your business, and it works as your business address with the Secretary of State | Many registrations, banks and directories will not accept a PO Box as a physical business address |
| Price | Posted on this site: from $140 a year for a small box (see mailbox pricing) | Priced by box size and post office; often cheaper at the smallest sizes |
When a PO Box is the better choice
Honestly: if everything you receive comes through the mail, the smallest box at the post office will usually cost less, and if your post office is closer to home than we are, it may be the more convenient stop. A PO Box is a perfectly good product for letters.
When a private mailbox wins
The private box earns its keep the first time a carrier other than USPS needs to deliver something that matters: a signature-required package, an oversized box, a business delivery to an address that is not your house. Add 24/7 access and staff who can sign, hold and hand you everything at one counter, and the difference stops being about mail and starts being about not missing deliveries.
Renting takes a few minutes in the store. See the mailbox page for sizes and how it works, or compare us with The UPS Store if you are choosing between private mailbox stores.
